Justin Northcutt
Posted by Webmaster in California, Hall of Shame, High Schools, ME-FV, Substitute Teachers
(07/30/08 – Initial BBT Report)
Justin Northcutt, 27, a former substitute teacher at Turlock Christian School in Turlock, California along with wife Amy Northcutt was arrested in early June on suspicion of distribution or exhibition of lewd material to a minor and annoying or molesting a child under 18.

The Northcutts are alleged to have sent sexually explicit cell phone messages and photos to a 16-year-old female student in an effort to arrange group sex with the girl.
The Stanislaus County district attorney’s office indicated on Tuesday that the Northcutts will face criminal charges although the exact nature of the charges was not revealed.
The Northcutts came to the attention of authorities by way of the girl’s mother, reportedly after Justin Northcutt was spotted talking to the alleged victim while she attended a family gathering.
Following his arrest Justin Northcutt was reportedly released on $25,000 bail.
07/31/08 – Felony Charge Filed
According to the Modesto Bee, the Northcutts have been each been charged with a single felony count of “harmful matter sent with intent of seduction of a minor”.
The Northcutts are scheduled for arraignment on September 3rd.
10/09/08 – Court Appearance
Justin and Amy Northcutt made a court appearance yesterday and entered not guilty pleas on individual felony counts of harmful matter sent with intent of seduction of a minor.
The Northcutts are scheduled to be back in court on December 17.
10/02/09 – No Contest Plea
Justin Northcutt has pleaded no contest in Stanislaus County Superior Court to felony charges after being accused of trying to arrange group sex with a 16-year-old student.
Under the terms of the plea deal, Justin Northcutt pleaded no contest to one felony count of “harmful matter sent with intent of seduction of a minor” and will serve three months in jail and will be required to register as a sex offender.
The Northcutts will be eligible to have their charges reduced to misdemeanors after three years on probation.
10/28/09 – Formal Sentencing
Justin Northcutt has been sentenced to three months in jail, ordered to register as sex offender and attend sex offender counseling and stay away from the victim.
Northcutt must report to jail by the end of November.
References:
Former Turlock teachers sentenced (10/28/09)
Ex-teachers plead no contest to trying to seduce teen girl (10/02/09)
Turlock teachers deny guilt in seduction case (10/09/08)
Turlock teachers charged with felonies in sex case (07/31/08)
Ex-Turlock Christian School teachers charged with molesting student (07/30/08)

Entries (RSS)
Family of the Victim, Yeah, I always felt that this website was a place for the victims. I can’t stand it when people defend pedophiles. What did the Northcutt’s (scum bags) say at the impact sentencing?
Did those scum bags cry like the chicken hawk cowards they are?
I hope now that Justin and Amy Northcutt have finally Plead GUILTY in court
( just like they plead guilty when the were arrested and confessed to the sheriffs and detectives in June of 2008)
all of you who say Justin was so nice and Amy was so pure and innocent in school realize that was then and do you really know a person 100% in school I don’t think so.
I hope and pray you now have sympathy for the Victim ( a 16 year old naive CHILD) and not the GUILTY party’s Justin and Amy Northcutt who are now REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS!!!!
This guy looks like a balding and greasy douche bag. This just shows you that a whole lot of game can get you laid in this world.
I went to school with Amy for years and was pretty good friends with her. She was the sweetest and one of the nicest girls I knew. She would never have done something like this. She was one of the most wholesome and honest girls I knew. I think people need to be careful what they say when they don’t know these people or the circumstances. Good Luck Amy!
Andrew,
You clearly don’t have children….or at least none who are at the fragile and impressionable age of being a teenager. As a parent of a 16 year old, I resent to the Nth degree and find deplorable and disgusting the actions of the Northcutts. I include in my sentiments, anyone who makes excuses for, or justifies by citing age of consent laws, why it should be considered no big deal for an adult (especially one in a position of authority and trust) to take advantage of the naivety of a young teen experiencing the beginnings of their sexual maturation…and the urges and drives that go with it.
To my knowledge, all age of consent laws that allow for those under the age of 18 to consent to sex have one or both of the following provisions:
- A defined maximum age difference between the minor and adult involved in the sexual activity, or
- Require parental consent.
So I think you got it wrong if you think all you need to do to absolve yourself of all responsibility is have a signed statement by that under-aged girl that she agrees to the sexual contact. How you came to such an ignorant point of view is beyond me. But hey, feel free to carry around a pre-completed form ready for signature the next time you find a yourself in a position where you have a willing teen at your disposal. I’m sure after showing said signed form to any police officer who stumbled upon you boinking a 16 year old, that they will apologize profusely for the intrusion and invite you to continue with your fornicating with the minor with their blessings.
Your statements shows you to be both clueless and ignorant of the issues surrounding the healthy social and sexual development of a teenager. In my opinion, you have a bit of growing up to do my friend.
I grew up with Justin Northcutt in Escalon, Ca. Justin did not party and was the varsity QB. His wife was in a college geology class with me but did not smoke or drink either. What they did is not a big deal, a simple sexual indiscrection at best. You know one state over in NV, you can have sex with a 16 yr old as long as she signs a letter of consent. Good luck Justin.
In keeping with site policies as outlined in the “Comments” page the site moderator has altered to an initial only the last name of the person purported to have left this comment.
He got 25,000 bail, she got 10,000. She actually wasn’t nearly as much involved as he was. They’re both wrong but I do think he should have a more severe punishment
It’ll be interesting to see if he and his wife get the same sentence for the same crime, or will she get a lesser one because she’s a chick. I’m betting his wife gets the chick discount. Time will tell…